As part of posting to Kairosnews, I've often thought about linking and what is the proper way to compose a link. Thus, I was excited to find Robin Skyler over at ambiguous.org posting some interesting ideas on The Syntax of Links.
First, I like what Skyler has to say about quoted phrases and linking. In the case where a quote is short and made into a hyperlink, it does seem appropriate to leave the quotes off.
Next, I'm glad that Skyler confronts the use of underlining titles versus using links. I've come to the conclusion that eventually, we will move to using italics only, not underlines, to denote titles of texts in both print and online so that it's easier to discriminate a title versus a hyperlink.
How about punctuation and links? Does an end puncutation get included in a link, like in a quote where we include the comma or period inside the quotation marks? Skyler points out that including the punctuation is the "tacit standard." It has always seemed better to me since the punctuation does not correspond semantically to the linked text. Plus, if the link is used again later in a text, it may not have some end punctuation associated with it; consistency in linking is one of the more accepted standards.
Anyone else have an ideas for thinking about the syntax of linking? For example, i've been wondering when and if we should include articles in front of a noun as part of a hyperlink.



A Grammar of Links
Was just thinking it would be interesting to do a survey of style and grammar handbooks and see if any syntax of linking is being introduced. Seems that the hyperlink should be covered in these texts, but the only place I can remember seeing it are in web writing/web design guides, not within the standard handbooks students use in college English classes. Anyone seen coverage of link syntax within them?
Re: A Grammar of Links
Well, the handbook I assign for my students (Raimes' Keys for Writers) only has one piece of advice, and only for e-mail: put all links at the end of the e-mail message, otherwise readers may not read your entire message.
Personally I think this is bad advice. If the link is useful at a particular point in the message, it should be provided then. By the time you get to the end of the message, the link might be irrelevant.
A link to confirm my point....
Re: A Grammar of Links
We are using The Longman Writer's Companion which only briefly mentions links, according to the index, in two places, neither of which discuss good link writing practices.
Seems worth considering, too, since students use links in Word documents which can be hot if opened in Word, or especially if converted to HTML.
Maybe we need to come up with a style guide for links :)