Motivating Students to Use Peer-Reviewed Sources

I shortened the title for the subject line from the original one, "Web-Loving Students Can Be Prodded to Cite Peer-Reviewed Works in Term Papers, Study Suggests." One professor did a close scrutiny of student papers, specifically bibliographies, over a period of years. He found that, by making source selection a significant part of the grade, students would use higher-quality, peer-reviewed sources. This article gives more details of the study and recommends more pedagogical collaboration between instructors and librarians.

Unfortunately, I've also found that the most effective way to communicate to *all* the students in my class a principle I consider important is, yes, to make it part of the grade. And while this article doesn't look like an argument against all that shoddy, pseudo-academic trash that passes for scholarship online, I did smell a hint of the assumption that online journals don't have a peer review process, something I talk about a little more here, in case anyone is interested.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Re: Motivating Students to Use Peer-Reviewed Sources

The bias in the headline from the Chronicle article runs even deeper -- the original headline implies that you can't use the Web if you want to find peer-reviewed sources. Many library databases are accessible via web-based interface, and I've often encountered students who believe that professors who restrict the number of web resources won't accept a source if it comes up in response to a database search. Of course, I also find students using commercial, non-academic resources such as findarticles.com, so we really do need to educate students about good online research strategies.

Clancy's picture

Re: Motivating Students to Use Peer-Reviewed Sources

That link is GREAT! I'm probably going to send it to my students.

Re: Motivating Students to Use Peer-Reviewed Sources

Thanks. I aim to please.