Accademic Blogging and Hiring

Here are a couple of links to articles discussing how academic blogging can negatively affect a person's job prospects:

http://chronicle.com/jobs/2005/07/2005070801c.htm

http://arstechnica.com/news.ars/post/20050711-5080.html

The former is from the Chronicle of Higher Education while the latter is a personal narrative from Hannibal, a well-known technology commentator on Ars Technica. Perhaps most interesting is Hannibal's objective statement that graduate students simply shouldn't blog under their own names, nor should they respond to controversial forums. The benefits do not outweigh the possible consequences. (I wonder how much jeopardy I am putting myself in through this comment.)

I think what these articles reiterate is something that should be obvious to anyone in academia: you function through a persona. That persona must be maintained and nurtured like a backyard vegetable garden in sunny Lafayette, Indiana. As always, we must be judicious in the presence we construct. The technological possibilities for information exchange have outstripped academia's capacity or desire to absorb them. This isn't merely a case of "don't put anything online you wouldn't want hiring panels to read," but rather, construct your online academic persona in such a way that what is associated with it is productive and targetted. Demosthenes mentioned something about delivery...

(In the interest of—ahem—full disclosure, I should point out that although I do occasionally comment to blogs like this one, I have never been much of blog participant due to its almost overwhelming noise to signal ratio. I feel that although blogs can be productively deployed in some scenarios, the blog is being over-applied and will suffer an inevitable backlash [which these articles may suggest]. As such, I do not publish a blog, although I do post current works in progress and some biographical information on my homepage.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
cel4145's picture

ars technica

I hadn't seen Hannibal's piece (even though I read Ars pretty regularly). Sort of suprised he says "don't blog." Part of my thinking about how blogging can work to the positive is that I want someone to hire me for who I am, not necessarily just an artificial personna constructed for the job market. That doesn't mean that I don't keep in mind that those less familiar with blogs in the academy will be reading my blog at some point. Merely that I hope that they *do* have the right information to figure out if I'm a good fit in a department.

Defending blogging

Matthew Kirschenbaum has an interesting response to Tribble, provides an argument for blogging, and ends with this suggestion:

If anyone needs an answer as to “why blog,” an utterly crass, careerist answer (as befits the Chronicle), here’s one: networking . First, go read Phil Agre’s “ Networking on the Network .” Then ask a blogger how their blog has paid off in terms of networking dividends. Bet they’ll have some stories to tell. In fact, why don’t we do just that? Would all academic bloggers reading this consider posting a comment or a trackback entry about some specific professional dividend that their online presence in the blogosphere has garnered for them?

Share you story at http://www.otal.umd.edu/~mgk/blog/archives/000813.html.

Blog Quietly

I can Google my posts to newsgroups dating back the the 1980s. I have been the sysop of a BBS and to this day moderate a mailing list on Continental Philosophy. Anyone interested can learn just about anything, if they look hard enough.

My Web site on writing is used in my courses, dating back to my part-time work at a community college in the 1990s. What worries me about those pages is that I still locate errors, despite all the reviewing and editing over the years. With my luck, a university hiring committee will locate the dozen errors I have missed and consider my skills lacking.

I do have blogs, but not under my name. They aren't really for the public, but I also want easy access to them from anywhere I might be. I post on teaching rhetoric and on political issues. I'm not about to attach my name to either, since doing so could adversely affect my career. I have pondered pulling down the blogs, but they replaced sections of my Web sites.

I did pull my poetry and all my theatrical scripts from the Web. I found it was much to easy to offend people.

- CSW